My mom made me co-sign a car with her when I was young because her credit was bad and she really needed a car. She stopped paying for the car and now it has been charged off. I am worried about not being able to do things like get an apartment because of it - is there anything I can do?
asked Jul 17, 2021 at 16:38
-
52Can you simply pay for the car? Which is what a co-signer is supposed to do.– jamesqfCommented Jul 17, 2021 at 16:42
-
18What happened to the car? Did the bank repossess it?– TTTCommented Jul 17, 2021 at 18:24
-
43How old were you when you co-signed? Did she force you to co-sign in any way? I wonder if the cosignership could be overturned by a court because of circumstances (I'm skeptical, but it might be worth researching)...– marcelmCommented Jul 18, 2021 at 12:46
-
11What kind of lender would accept a co-signer young enough to be coerced by their parent (presumably with little or no credit history, maybe not even any income) on a loan? Sounds utterly sketchy, probably doing all sorts of illegal things. I think if you pursued this legally they'd be in deep shit, not necessarily because of the legality of the co-signing, but all the other stuff you'd turn up on them.– R.. GitHub STOP HELPING ICECommented Jul 18, 2021 at 16:20
-
14Though "young" is not precise. The OP might be in their 20s or even 30s, and still think of that as young. I've known a number of people who were still under their parents' thumbs at those ages.– jamesqfCommented Jul 18, 2021 at 16:27
|
Show 15 more comments
6 Answers
Your Mom has really messed up your finances.
As cosigner you are liable for the whole of the debt on the car. And worse, you have no right to use the car or even stop your Mom using it. Your Mom used you to get a loan which her finances didn't entitle her to, and by failing to pay it doomed you to the same terrible financial circumstances which she got herself into. As an adult, presumably with a decade or two of experience of how finance works, she shouldn't have done that.
By the way, you should have been contacted by the loan company long before the debt was charged off. That would have been the time to take action. The fact that a loan has been charged off will already have had a negative effect on your credit.
Your first step should definitely be to contact the loan company and find out 1) if the car has been repossessed 2) how much debt is outstanding. Not talking to the loan company will only make things worse.
You have two options:
- Pay off the debt your mom owes, which you should be able to do by making the same payments your Mom was making. If, as Harper says, the car has already been repossessed then the debt will be less than the value of the car, and this may be achievable. It's definitely the best option, because the other one is...
- Fail to pay off the loan, and take the hit to your credit. This will prevent you getting any kind of credit for a long time, and may well affect things like your ability to get an apartment.
You can try a couple of things:
- contact your Mom and try to persuade her to pay the outstanding debt (or some of it). If the car hasn't been repossessed maybe you can sell it and pay back some of the loan;
- contact the loan company, explain the situation, and see if they will accept easier repayment terms, and possibly a lower total payment. Harper suggests you do this through a lawyer, and that may be a good idea despite the cost.
Also make a vow to never cosign a loan again.
answered Jul 18, 2021 at 1:20
-
39Fraxinus: my rule as a grown up and not young adult is that you never, ever, in a million years, co-sign. Pay for them if you can afford it and really want to. Or don’t pay. Never co-sign. Making your kid co-sign is positively evil. Commented Jul 18, 2021 at 21:23
-
2@gnasher729 When being in the debt trap already, but short of victims ... and as usual, one can ignore the reality (having signed a legally binding contract), but not the consequences (full lability for whatever one has signed for). Commented Jul 18, 2021 at 21:41
-
1@GS-ApologisetoMonica As requested, this is being discussed on meta. The consensus is not in your favour (if saying so won't cause you to delete this comment) Commented Jul 21, 2021 at 9:39
-
1The conclusion of the meta discussion is in the comments on my answer there. Commented Jul 21, 2021 at 13:10
In addition to DJClayworth's excellent answer, there may be one other option - but it depends a lot on the details of how this co-signing happened as well as specific laws in your jurisdiction. You've mentioned that she "made you" sign the contract, but haven't provided any details on what that force consisted of. In many places, contracts made under duress are not legally enforceable. For example, if she was threatening to harm you. If so, it might be possible to no longer be responsible for the debt, and perhaps to clear it from your history.
However, you absolutely need to speak to a contract lawyer to explore this option - there's far too much legal complexity involved for randoms on the Internet to give a definitive answer on this.
-
20For example “you co-sign for the car or I’ll throw you out” could be duress. On the other hand, normally it would be the opposing party (the car dealer) putting you under duress, and the dealer can rightfully say they did nothing wrong. Therefore: A lawyer. Commented Jul 18, 2021 at 21:27
-
6If OP was a minor at the time they co-signed, then their signature would likely be voidable at their option (or, depending on the jurisdiction, it might be void ab initio). However, the lender would know this, and refuse to accept a minor's co-signature, so I doubt this is actually the case.– KevinCommented Jul 19, 2021 at 1:00
-
1Also, telling a court that you're not liable for the car because your mom forced you to sign it might cause a degree of strain in your relationship with her, especially if the bank then proceeds to repossess it... Commented Jul 19, 2021 at 14:35
-
2@nick012000 From the mother's perspective, sure. I'd be willing to bet, however, that the OP is already feeling some strain on the relationship.– chepnerCommented Jul 19, 2021 at 16:26
"Charge-off" means 90-180 days have passed since she stopped paying, and the creditor has decided payment in the near future is unlikely. It's a tax status for them. However, it does not erase the debt.
You need to pay for the car
You agreed to co-sign so you are responsible for paying for the car, unless you signed while not of legal age, or were coerced.
You knew that when you co-signed, and if that resulted in some temporary peace in the family, now is when you pay for that. You knew the score. So it's time to adult up.
I gather by the fact that the debt was "charged off" that the car has already been repossessed. Now it just comes down to money ($$$$). They will have sold off the automobile, reducing the debt somewhat, and you need to pay the remaining debt.
Contact a lawyer or your local legal aid. Have them negotiate with the company that you will pay an amount to settle the matter in full. A condition of the deal is that the debt will be completely and totally removed from your credit report, and neither of you will disparage the other in any way including credit reporting. Most creditors will agree to this if it means getting paid. Also I recommend adding a condition that you agree there is a genuine dispute as to the validity of the debt, and so, any amount they consider forgiven will not be treated as income. That will keep you from paying some taxes.
The lawyer can dot all the I's and cross all the T's.
Wait until both you and they have signed the contract before sending any money.
Then you write a fat check and you're free and clear.
If you don't pay
Then the creditor will hold onto the debt for awhile, on the off chance you do decide to start paying. After awhile, it will "sell off the debt" to another company. That company will make collection efforts against you. After awhile, they will sell your debt to another company. They too will make collection efforts against you. This could go on for 20 years, although after 3-6 years they will lose the right to sue you for the money.
Your best outcome will happen if you settle with the original creditor. Once they sell the debt, that becomes impossible, since they don't own the debt anymore. Therefore you lose the ability to haggle with them to stop reporting it to credit bureaus. It's on your credit report for good at that point.
By "for good" I mean for 7 years after the last payment.
Yes, it will suck to find an apartment during that time. Your best bet there will be "housemate share situations", which are a cramped lifestyle, but at least you are homed, in the locale you desire. If you are crafty, you can also consider Tiny House on friends' property, or buying cheap land and building a Tiny House... or even #VanLife.
answered Jul 20, 2021 at 4:51
Harper - Reinstate MonicaHarper - Reinstate Monica
58.9k10 gold badges93 silver badges197 bronze badges
Unfortunately, "charge-off" doesn't mean that your obligation is gone. You could still hear from debt collectors for a long time if you don't address the issue now. You could contact the creditor and try to settle your debt.
It may be tempting to not pay a charge-off, since your lender has likely stopped trying to collect on the account. But as long as the debt is yours, you’re legally responsible for it until it’s …
- Paid
- Settled
- Discharged in a bankruptcy filing
Plus, that charge-off can hurt your chances of getting a loan — some lenders may ask you to pay all outstanding debt before you can take out a mortgage or other type of loan.
answered Jul 19, 2021 at 19:03
Well because others might look at this for help...
#1 - You should never co-sign, ever. But...
#2 - If you do co-sign then your name should be on the title (alone) and write a contract signing over the car in their name after all payments. That way if they miss payments, you then sell the car/whatever and deal with it as quick as possible.
#3 - If they do not agree to this, you are back to #1.
-
4@blankip - Unless you're personally involved in the OP's dilemma, I don't see where you have any justification for your now-deleted first point. It's also possible that the mother fully intended on making all the payments at the time of the signing, and then had a setback of some sort. It's admittedly somewhat less likely because she needed a co-signer in the first place, but it's still feasible. If you do have first-hand knowledge, then stating that in your answer would at least justify leaving that statement in. I still think it'd be in bad taste, but it'd at least be justified.– BobsonCommented Jul 19, 2021 at 18:01
-
7I think there are two issues with your answer that can explain the downvotes for you, and it has nothing to do with the mod edit. First, your original point #1 is describing a person that you know nothing about. You have taken it a step further than DJClayworth to say that, not only did the mother do something wrong here, that she always does this as a pattern, which you don't know. You then go on to blame the OP, which I think many see as over the top. Second, your point #2 (originally #3) is probably not a smart idea. It is best to stick with "never co-sign." Commented Jul 19, 2021 at 18:11
-
1Third issue: this does absolutely nothing to attempt to solve OP's problem. It's as if the OP said "help, I'm pregnant" and the answer said "Well, you shouldn't have done the thing that made you get pregnant." - condescending and completely unhelpful. Commented Jul 21, 2021 at 9:48
-
@BenMiller-RememberMonica - why is point number 3 a bad idea? If you are going to co-sign no matter what, that is what you do. The person you are cosigning for is royally screwed over if they do not meet the payments (possibly if you choose to). This either leads to them fulfilling the obligation or just saying no thank you from the beginning. Point #1 is a generalization of an adult needing a co-signer - they only need it because they fail to pay debts in the past. Probably many times. Your analysis is poor and weak.– blankipCommented Jul 21, 2021 at 17:36
-
@blankip I go into a little more detail in my answer to your meta question. Commented Jul 21, 2021 at 18:36
If the lender has not pursued you for collection, don't do anything. If they do, refuse to take their calls or respond to their letters, and watch your credit report. If anything appears on it, contact the credit reporting agency and dispute the mark. Tell them the debt is not legitimate and that it was taken out by another person in your name. Do not offer any more details than that on the nature of the illegitimacy. You do not want to be making statements they can try to prove are false. You only want to deny the legitimacy of the debt and leave the lender with the burden of trying to prove it's legitimate (which they will likely fail to do).
Do not have any contact with the lender whatsoever. Any contact you make with them will be used by them as evidence that the debt is legitimate.
answered Jul 18, 2021 at 16:24
-
11do you think that the claim that "the debt is illegitimate" is true? Or are you proposing that OP attempts to get away with lying about the debt?– BrondahlCommented Jul 18, 2021 at 17:04
-
17‘My mom made me co-sign a car’ is the quote from the question. Sounds to me that OP signed, not that their name was used fraudulently or without their knowledge. If the debt really isn’t legitimate I agree with your answer, but it seems OP signed, it seems we need clarification from OP– quidCommented Jul 18, 2021 at 18:13
-
7Are there possible legal repercussions for lying about the debt not being theirs when it legally is?– KatCommented Jul 18, 2021 at 18:32
-
3I do not advocate lying as part of this, rather being as terse as possible so as not to give the lender any information to use against you. Commented Jul 18, 2021 at 19:50
-
23First you said "Tell them the debt is not legitimate", and then you said "I do not advocate lying as part of this". The first statement is a lie, nevertheless you advocated it. Are you a politician?– TonyKCommented Jul 19, 2021 at 0:07