3

I've been looking at investing in another dividend stock, and I have been using dividata.com to do some research.

I have found several stocks that I am interested in that have a roughly 9% or 10% dividend yield. I also found The China Fund (NYSE: CHN) that has a 20% dividend. A 20% dividend is attractive, of course, but I'd rather not make a poor investment if that stock is not reliable.

I am confused about the information I am receiving about this specific stock. When looking at the data on dividata.com, it looks good in many respects:

https://dividata.com/stock/CHN

The stock price has grown from ~$5 to ~$17 per share in that time period, and quite steadily. dividata.com also says that they have a 22-year history of paying out dividends. The payout for the past 5 years has been fairly steady, although there have been some incontinuities in the recent past:

https://dividata.com/stock/CHN/dividend

This data does not match what I see on Google Finance, however:

https://www.google.com/finance?q=NYSE%3ACHN&ei=em22VaHXF6mWigK_6KOIBA

The stock price data on Google Finance is completely different that what I see on dividata.com. Also, Google Finance says that the dividend yield is 1.68% with a 0.30/share payout.

Can anyone tell me why there is inconsistencies in the data between the two sites? Why doesn't it match up?

  • The stock prices on the two sites look the same to me right now. Both are around $17.80. – dg99 Jul 31 '15 at 14:43
2

CHN is a Closed-End Fund.

CHN actually pays out three types of distributions:

  1. Standard cash dividends (these are cash dividends paid out by the constituent stocks held by the Closed-End Fund)
  2. Short-term capital gains
  3. Long-term capital gains

In the case of CHN, they appear to be paying yearly. The most recent dividend, with exdate of 18 Dec 2014, consisted of $3.4669 of Long-term capital gains and $0.2982 cash dividend.

Prior to that, the dividend with exdate of 19 Dec 2013 consisted of $2.8753 long-term capital gains and $0.4387 cash dividend.

For a standard dividend yield you typically would not expect short-term and long-term capital events to be included in a yield calculation, as these events really only occur in relation to a fund rebalancing (changing its investments) and are not really due to the actual performance of the fund in any way. Most free sites that provide dividend information do not make a distinction on the dividend type.

Data source: Premium Data

Full Disclosure: I am a co-owner of Premium Data/Norgate.

1

The yield on Div Data is showing 20% ((3.77/Current Price)*100)) because that only accounts for last years dividend. If you look at the left column, the 52 week dividend yield is the same as google(1.6%). This is calculated taking an average of n number of years. The data is slightly off as one of those sites would have used an extra year.

  • If you hover over "52 week dividend yield" it says that it is calculated from only over the past 12 months, not the past n years. Also: this doesn't explain the discrepancies in the stock price data. Any reason why dividata's stock price chart differs from Google Finance or Yahoo Finace? – David Jul 28 '15 at 14:02
  • Then there is a glitch in the site. They mention "Sum of dividends paid in the last 12 months divided by the closing price on the prior day". They also mention that a dividend of $3.765 was paid on 12/18/14 which was the only dividend within the last 12 months. 3.765/17.83 is roughly 21% and not 1.6%. – user19894 Jul 28 '15 at 14:47

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.