I received a Voluntary Warrant Exercise offer to convert 15 warrants to common shares at $11.50 per share for a total cost of $173.

The warrants held were trading at $18 each with a cost basis of $32 for a total cost of $480. Taking the offer appeared to offer some relief on the current loss. Not fully understanding the accounting and/or the rationale of the process, I agreed to act on the offer.

Merrill's agent advised me that I would have to pay an additional $173 plus a $30 fee for a total of $203. Thinking that the funds would be reversed at the completion of the conversion, I agreed and provided the additional funds. Today's Gain/Loss statement shows my cost basis per share is $43 per share for a total cost of $649.

In retrospect, I could have sold the warrants at market at $18 each and taken my loss. Then I could have purchased the common at $30 for a cost basis of $30 each. Can you help and explain the accounting and was the conversion handled properly.


It has been a really long time since I've dealt with warrants. I did a lot of IPO's in the late 90's that were a combination of common and one or more warrants - so take this with a grain of salt.

There are some rounding errors in your calculations. And the $32 and $30 cost per share of the common is confusing - it throws the comparison off. I'm going to use $32 throughout.

Your cost warrant basis is $172.50 (15 x $11.50).

Your purchase price of the common is $32 for a total of $480.

Therefore, the cost basis per share is $43.50 (compared to $43) and the total cost basis is $652.50 (compared to $649).

The one glaring issue that I see is that your warrants were trading below intrinsic value. Therefore, selling them at that price would not have been a good idea since you would have had to pay more for the exercise. At $32 they should have been worth $20.50 apiece (compared to $18):

(15 * $18) - (15 * $32) = $210 (compared to $172.50).

To make the comparison simpler, I ignored the $30 commission.

Call your broker and ask for a better explanation and post some feedback if you get one.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.