I'm investigating the "best" approach towards my medical student debt. My outstanding debt is $400,000 with an interest rate of 6.8%. Presently, FAFSA is my Lender. I'm on the 10-year plan, which requires a monthly payment of $5000.

I looked at other options, namely SOFI. This company quoted me the following options:

  • 5 year term @ $8000 a month w/ interest rate of 4.75%
  • 7 year term @ $6000 a month w/ interest rate of 4.73%
  • 10 year term @ $4662 a month w/ interest rate of 4.73%
  • 15 year term @ $3500 a month w/ interest rate of 4.9%
  • 20 year term @ $2900 a month w/ interest rate of 5%

I've considered keeping my FAFSA Lender and choosing Income-Based Repayment (IBR). That would result in a monthly payment of 10-15% of my income. So, at an income of ~$11,000 a month, I'd pay $1100 a month. That's much lower and IBR will, as I understand, "forgive" the remainder of my debt after 20 years. However, the draw to that forgiveness, as I understand, is that will be treated as taxable income. So, if by the time 20 years expires, I will have had $200,000 left in debt, I'd have a tax bill of 30% * $200,000, or $60,000.

In short, choosing a private lender seems better than FAFSA, but I'm torn.

Please advise me on the pros and cons of each: FAFSA versus Private Lender. I'm definitely interested in any other suggestions too?

  • Are you sure the 5 year term is 4.75%? Seems like it should be slightly lower rather than higher. And how much can you afford per month right now? – TTT Jun 27 '18 at 14:15
  • I think you should update with actual numbers instead of rounding. (Some seem to be way off by hundreds per month.) Your current payment shouldn't be more than $4603/month. – TTT Jun 27 '18 at 16:28

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.