Will I most likely owe money during tax season if I claim the first two allowances on the W-4 instead of just the first one?

I was filling it out at a new job (14/hr) full-time (40/hrs per week) and I claimed the first two allowances on the form since:

  1. No one else can claim me as a dependent.

  2. I'm single and have only one job.

The HR employee told me I'd probably owe taxes if I did two instead of just the first one.

Is this true?

  • It's impossible to say without knowing more about your situation. For instance, if you can deduct a lot of mortgage or student loan interest, or have other itemized deductions, you might still be over-withholding.
    – jamesqf
    Commented Aug 4, 2017 at 18:03

1 Answer 1


In general, following the W-4 instructions should result in withholdings that are fairly close to the amount of taxes that you will owe for the year, particularly if your situation is relatively uncomplicated. Claiming less withholdings than the form suggests can help ensure that you end up saving money in your "interest-free IRS savings account" and get a refund at the end of the year, which some people prefer so they don't need to budget separately for a tax payment. I'm guessing that the HR employee either prefers doing so himself or has on occasion received complaints from other employees that they "didn't take enough out".

Personally, I'd prefer to claim as many withholdings as I can, and be sure to have some money aside in case it turns out that I have to owe a little bit, since it means I get more take-home pay throughout the year.

It's good to keep in mind that a W-4 isn't written in stone. If it turns out that too much or too little is being taken out, you can always change it. You can also try playing around with the IRS withholding calculator to try some scenarios.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .