My tax accountants are charging us $800 ($400 each for my wife & I) for our state and federal returns this year.

Our returns are fairly simple, so I'm wondering if I'm getting any real value out of the service. How can I tell?

  • Excellent question! I've often wondered how to evaluate tax accountants as well.
    – Alex B
    Apr 18, 2011 at 15:50

3 Answers 3


Depending on your personal situation and the complexity of your tax return, your quoted price of $400 per person does seem a bit expensive.

This is of course a tradeoff between your own time and expertise vs. that of your tax preparer.

One way to do a level-set would be to use an online tax service to prepare your own. Most of these are free to use, until you want to file. Once you have filled out your taxes from your original documentation, check the generated return against your paid/prepared return.

Did your tax preparer find more for you, or did you do an equivalent job? Did you enjoy (or at least not hate) the experience of doing it yourself? Would you have used the time you saved to do something else?

Personally I have been using software for many years, and have a medium-complex (Canadian) return. My father, on the other hand, did his own until he retired. Then with the complexity of pension income vs. other income, and the various benefits to deduct, he has started to use an accountant. He deems it a small price to pay to avoid the aggravation that it was causing him.

Good Luck

  • 1
    Agreed, the only real way to tell is do it yourself and compare. If the experience wasn't horrifying and you can see you doing it yourself, then you have your answer. If not, as with duffbeer's plumber, you may find it easier to let someone else do it.
    – Turukawa
    Apr 17, 2011 at 17:36
  • I'd like to add another option if you don't want to do it yourself: Use the $400 one and the cheapest one you can find. Does the return make up for the difference in what they charge?
    – user3377
    Apr 19, 2011 at 4:03
  • Agreed, try it yourself online (I use HRBlock, there are others). Since its free until actually filing, it only costs you some time. If you come close, you can save the money. Also, the following year you'll save time b/c the tool will remember some of your information. If it can import W-2, then it'll be real nice. Took me about an hour this year, granted for a pretty straightforward tax return. Also, in my state the state itself has a website, and its free there. Apr 19, 2011 at 19:42

From a strictly financial perspective, you're almost certainly not getting value out of it. Tax software costs like $50.

The real question is "Do I want to do my taxes?". I can pay a plumber $300 to replace a toilet, or spend a few hours to do it myself.

  • 2
    Interesting analogy. Years ago, I had my 5yr old daughter change a broken dimmer in our house, just to prove a point. I spoke, I pointed, I touched nothing. Electricians are $100 just to walk in the door. I suspect Scott's return may take a couple hours the first year, but no more. Apr 18, 2011 at 12:45
  • I agree in general but remember accountant doesn't just fill out the return. He'll represent you in case of an audit. They probably answer your questions a little better than turbotax.
    – Vitalik
    Apr 18, 2011 at 14:02
  • @Vitalik I thought that varied based on the accountant.
    – Alex B
    Apr 18, 2011 at 15:52
  • @Alex B, hmmm, i would think if they put their name on the bottom of the return they have to be responsible... otherwise what's the point. But i was just trying to be logical. Maybe you are right.
    – Vitalik
    Apr 18, 2011 at 16:00

Disclaimer - As my profile here indicates, I am a paid guest blogger at the TurboTax site. I've used TurboTax since my 1984 return, and never paid a preparer, so my experience is second-hand. Friends have showed me the "checklist/organizer" their tax guy supplies them. It has boxes to fill in to list things like mortgage interest, charitable donations, etc. These translate directly to the entry forms on the tax forms and therefore, the tax software. The tax guy then gives it to a clerk to enter into the same software you'd pay $50 for and he may glance at the return. If you are in the 25% bracket, your guy would need to "find" $3200 in items you'd have missed for you to break even.

My suggestion is that you look at your last few returns and ask yourself if every single entry was for items you had at your fingertips. There are a few things the individual would easily miss, when filing by hand, such as the Make Work Pay tax credit, but the software handles these things automatically.

Further, it makes sense to spend the $50, even though I assume you're done with your return. Spend the time, enter the data you supplied the tax guy. If you can then say that he added value, that's fine, if the returns are identical (or perhaps he even missed something) there's your answer.

To Duff's point, you should see how much incremental time it took to use the software now that your tax folder has all the paperwork. Last simple return I did with someone took 45 minutes. Income, interest, mortgage interest, prop tax, IRA withdrawal, donations. That was about it.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.