Partner had a minor accident in the car. No one was hurt – basically scraped the side of a concrete wall so there are a few small dents and ugly scratches everywhere along the front of my car.

I'm considering making a claim as the damage should be more than the $500 excess. But I've only had the car for about 3-4 years or so now and this is the first half-expensive car I've ever bought so I've never had comprehensive insurance.

So I was wondering if I make the claim, given my short history of being insured, is it likely to just increase my premium? I don't mind paying the $500 excess to get it fixed but basically, it's just cosmetic damage – car is still driveable. But if say, my insurance increases by $200-300 every year after this, I'll end up paying much more in the long run due to increase premiums, and then I'm probably not willing to fix it. I plan to drive this car for many years and by the time I sell, the scratches are not going to affect the resale value by more than a few thousand dollars in extra premiums.

Do insurance companies in Australia increase premiums after you make a claim?


They may go up.

Or they may not.

Personally, if the costs of your cosmetic fixes aren't that much more than your deductible (get quotes ahead of time), I wouldn't report it.

I had a similar case where the damage I incurred bumping a parking space divider was $600. There was no point in reporting a claim, as my deductible was $500.

  • 2
    In the UK, when renewing your insurance you have to declare all incidents that could have given rise to a claim on the policy, whether or not you actually claimed. But it may be different in Australia.
    – Mike Scott
    Feb 17 '17 at 13:28
  • @MikeScott - I missed the Australia tag. I answered based on US experience.
    – warren
    Feb 17 '17 at 15:21
  • @MikeScott What you're supposed to do and what is a smart choice are not always the same. Would you honestly tell your insurer if you got a scratch or bump on your car that you could repair cheaper than your excess+premium increase?
    – Philbo
    Feb 12 '18 at 14:50

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.