Due to a paperwork mixup of my own doing (incorrectly added her as a domestic partner), a year's worth of insurance premiums paid on behalf of my wife were deducted post-tax instead of pre-tax.
The amounts are about 4,000 this year and about 2,000 last year.
My employer's payroll company cannot re-issue any payroll and cannot generate a corrected 1099.
Am I correct in assuming that I overpaid taxes for last year and this year? What is my recourse if I can't get corrected paperwork?