6

In the United States, Is it possible to buy and sell the same stock on the same day? I heard day traders can do this, and you need to have at minimum of 25K in the account in order to be a day trader. If I have 25K in my account, do I automatically become a day trader and be able to buy and sell the same stock on the same day? Or I have to apply for it? Do all stock brokers allow you to do day trades? I guess my question is are are the steps for becoming a day trader, so I can buy and sell stocks on the day?

Note: I understand there are risks. I am looking for how to do it, because every time I buy a stock I have to wait at least 3 days before I can sell it.

  • 1
    You can buy a stock today and sell it later the same day. This does not necessarily make you a day trader. As Chris asked, what country are you in? As different countries may have different rules on what defines a day trader. In Australia, being a day trader only matters in regards to how your profits and losses are taxed. – Victor Jul 11 '16 at 0:09
  • What's with the downvote? Seems like a legitimate question. – JohnFx Jul 11 '16 at 0:58
  • 1
    Note that this will be subject not only to short-term tax rates but to the "wash rule". And I agree with @DanielAnderson that this is a good way to lose your shirt unless you are willing to spend top-level amounts of time and effort on it. Long-term investment is a positive-sum game. Day trading isn't, and has you playing in direct competition with the pros... and if you don't see the sucker at the poker table he's sitting in your chair. – keshlam Jul 11 '16 at 12:49
  • I've updated the question, my question applies to the United States. – s-hunter Jul 11 '16 at 13:43
  • ah I see the risk averse knights of asset protection have arrived. totally irrelevant answers to OPs question – CQM Jul 11 '16 at 16:23
7

Because it takes 3 business days for the actual transfer of stock to occur after you buy or sell to the next owner, your cash is tied up until that happens. This is called the settlement period.

Therefore, brokers offer "margin", which is a form of credit, or loan, to allow you to keep trading while the settlement period occurs, and in other situations unrelated to the presented question. To do this you need a "margin account", you currently have a "cash account".

The caveat of having a retail margin account (distinct from a professional margin account) is that there is a limited amount of same-day trades you can make if you have less than $25,000 in the account. This is called the Pattern Day Trader (PDT) rule. You don't need $25k to day trade, you will just wish you had it, as it is easy to get your account frozen or downgraded to a cash account.

The way around THAT is to have multiple margin accounts at different brokerages. This will greatly increase the number of same day trades you can make.

Many brokers that offer a "solution" to PDT to people that don't have 25k to invest, are offering professional trading accounts, which have additional fees for data, which is free for retail trading accounts.

This problem has nothing to do with:

  • preventing you from inadvertently running afoul of wash-sale rules
  • sneakily selling you on trading desks
  • sneakily promoting long term investing
  • trying to prevent you from subjecting yourself to short term tax rates

So be careful of the advice you get on the internet. It is mostly white noise. Feel free to verify

  • I'm not trying to prevent the OP from running into wash or short-term tax rates. If you think you can beat the odds by enough to overcome those drags, go for it; just remember the difference between paper gains and real money, and don't put yourself in a position where you can lose more than you can afford to lose. – keshlam Jul 11 '16 at 18:46
  • @keshlam all good, I just made a list of red herrings hoping the community will not do it next time – CQM Jul 11 '16 at 18:50
  • 1
    I think a warning that one is entering the higher-risk area is appropriate. Of course return and risk are coupled, so for some it may be a game worth playing, but go in with eyes open. – keshlam Jul 11 '16 at 18:53
  • @keshlam I don't, it is worth noting that I've been dinged many times on this forum for giving correct answers to questions because they don't detail consequences, as if that omission condones it. – CQM Jul 11 '16 at 20:37
  • 1
    @keshlam upvotes masquerade as correctness. – CQM Jul 11 '16 at 22:34
2

You should not have to wait 3 days to sell the stock after purchase. If you are trading with a cash account you will have to wait for the sale to settle (3 business days) before you can use those funds to purchase other stock.

If you meet the definition of a pattern day trader which is 4 or more day trades in 5 business days then your brokerage will require you to have a minimum of $25,000 in funds and a margin account.

  • Gee, in Australia if I sold a stock today my broker lets me use the funds from that sale to buy another stock before the T+3 days are up, I cannot withdraw those funds before T+3 but can use them for trading, and I do not have a margin account just a standard account. Also I can buy a stock today and sell it today without being classed as a day trader. – Victor Jul 11 '16 at 22:00
  • Actually from March 2016 Australia now has T+2 settlement for cash equites. – Victor Jul 11 '16 at 22:43
  • @Victor you can buy and sell the same day without being classified as a day trader depending on the frequency you do that. The rules in Australia may be different than the US, here it is 4 day trades in 5 business days to be classified as a pattern day trader. I could regularly trade up to that but as long as I don't meet that definition I will not be classified as a "pattern day trader". – homer150mw Jul 12 '16 at 13:16
  • My main point was about the repurchase of a new stock after the sale of an existing stock. Also my point on day trading is based on a single trade in and out on the same day - the OP mentions nothing about multiple trades. Of course the frequency of these type of trades would determine whether someone is a day trader or not, which the definition of and rules may differ from country to country. – Victor Jul 12 '16 at 13:30
  • @brick to avoid issues with "free riding" the account owner would simply need to wait for the sale to settle before using those funds to purchase shares of the same or a different stock. The OP's question didn't address free riding so I didn't address it beyond stating that he would need to wait to use the proceeds from the sale in a cash account. – homer150mw Jul 12 '16 at 15:38
1

If you're going to be a day trader, you really need to know your stuff. It's risky, to say the least.

One of the most important elements to being successful is having access to very fast data streams so that you can make moves quickly as trends stat to develop in the markets. If you're planning on doing this using consumer-grade sites like eTrade, that's not a good idea. The web systems of many of the retail brokerage firms are not good enough to give you data fast enough for you to make good, timely decisions or to be able to execute trades way that day traders do in order to make their money. Many of those guys are living on very thin margins, sometimes just a few cents of movement one way or the other, so they make up for it with a large volume of trades.

One of the reasons you were told you need a big chunk of money to day trade is that some firms will rent you out a "desk" and computer access to day trade through their systems if you're really serious about it. They will require you to put up at least a minimum amount of money for this privilege, and $25k may not be too far out of the ballpark.

If you've never done day trading before, be careful. It doesn't take much to get caught looking the wrong way on a trade that you can't get out of without losing your shirt unless you're willing to hold on to the stock, which could be longer than a day.

Day trading sounds very simple and easy, but it isn't. You need to learn about how it works (a good book to read to understand this market is "Flash Boys" by Michael Lewis, besides being very entertaining), because it is a space filled with very sophisticated, well-funded firms and individuals who spend huge sums of money to gain miniscule advantages in the markets.

Be careful, whatever you do. And don't play in day trading with your retirement money or any other money you can't afford to walk away from.

I hope this helps.

Good luck!

  • Thanks for the warning. I understand there are risks. I am looking for how to do it, because every time I buy a stock I have to wait at least 3 days before I can sell it. – s-hunter Jul 11 '16 at 13:45
  • 3
    @s-hunter - why do you have to wait 3 days, you can sell it whenever you want - why don't you check with your broker for the right answer for a question like this instead of strangers on the internet. – Victor Jul 11 '16 at 22:03
0

you need minimum of 25k otherwise youll reach a limit. you have to wait 3 days for the sale to clear unless youre on margin. dont buy anything based on idiots on twitter or the internet. however, theres some good people to follow though that know what theyre doing.

dont listen to this guy saying that etrade or those platforms arent fast enough. they all offer level 2 prices so i dont know what hes talking about. successful day traders arent buying and selling a stock every single day. theres not always something to buy and sell...unless youre just gambling, and in that case just go to the casino and lose your money there.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.