I have been learning about how to read and understand a stock company's income statement and using those variables to determine the worth of the stock. My question is, what is a good profit margin for a company that would make it worthwhile to invest, 5%? And what are the most important indicators to look at when making decision's based on the company's fundamentals.

  • 1
    Check for how sustainable is the profit rather than numbers only.
    – DumbCoder
    Mar 2 '11 at 8:33
  • Also note that you can't just look at margin and earnings and other features of the business. Investment is buying future-money with present-money, so you need to look at the price you're paying. For example: right now, Apple is trading for $360/share. Good deal? Beats me - but! all else being equal, it'd be a much better deal at $180/share and a much worse deal at $720. This is why the P/E ratio is still such a big deal, for all that earnings statements can be manipulated. (That said, looking at margins is still a very good idea.)
    – user296
    Mar 4 '11 at 21:39

The short answer is that it depends on the industry.

  • Retail: usually have low margins, 3-5% being a goodish range; some of the value traders can be even lower. Margin here is nothing compared to volume. If you're selling bags of potatoes and making a 2% margin, that's fantastic as long as you can use the income from the potatoes you sold five minutes ago to buy the potatoes you'll sell in the next five minutes.
  • Manufacturing: margins tend to be higher on specialised, high-end goods and lower on mass-produced, highly-competitive goods; could be anywhere from 5-20%.
  • Mining/Extraction: oil, coal, gold, you name it, usually very good margins but nailed by high tax rates and the globally set prices, so some sources only good at certain price points. A well-managed company will manage these fluctuations. Margins can be from 25-90%.
  • Services: amongst the highest margins but often the most likely to suffer incredible crashes since competition is fierce and barriers to entry low. Margins usually around 40-60%.

In other words, margin alone - even in comparison to peers - will not be a sufficient index to track company success. I'll mention Apple quickly as a special case that has managed to charge a premium margin for a mass-market product. Few companies can achieve this.

As with all investment analysis, you need to have a very clear understanding of the industry (i.e. what is "normal" for debt/equity/gearing/margin/cash-on-hand) as well as of the barriers-to-entry which competitors face.

A higher-than-normal margin may swiftly be undermined by competitors (Apple aside). Any company offering perpetual above-the-odds returns may just be a Ponzi scheme (Bernie Maddof, etc.). More important than high-margins or high-profits over some short-term track is consistency of approach, an ability to whether adverse cyclical events, and deep investment in continuity (i.e. the entire company doesn't come to a grinding halt when a crucial staff-member retires).

  • And the margin and the reason for the margin might vary from year to year for a company. Did they cut costs, or did they sell more?
    – MrChrister
    Mar 1 '11 at 21:57
  • Yeah, including, "Did they just lay off half their staff to achieve a quick margin boost?"
    – Turukawa
    Mar 2 '11 at 5:39

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.