4

I have 9 different debts (5 of which are student loans) each with a different interest rate (ranging from 3.4% APR to 10.9% APR). I want to find out in which order paying them off would take the least amount of time. The amount from each loan, once paid off, will be applied to the next (or a different) debt.

+-------+-----------+-------+-----------+
| Name  | Balance   | APR   | Minimum   |
+-------+-----------+-------+-----------+
| A     | 132.51    | 3.4   | 100       |
| B     | 1000      | 9.15  | 100       |
| C     | 2500      | 10.9  | 100       |
| D     | 8283.93   | 8.99  | 270       |
| E     | 6975.82   | 4.5   | 80        |
| F     | 7451.52   | 6.8   | 80        |
| G     | 7550.68   | 7.65  | 65        |
| H     | 12845.06  | 7.65  | 105       |
| I     | 15324.46  | 7.65  | 125       |
+-------+-----------+-------+-----------+

After one loan/debt is paid off, that monthly payments get carried over to the next one on the list. For example, in Month 1, I pay 100 on A (remaining balance ~ 32.51) and 100 on B (remaining balance ~900). Month 2 I pay 32.51 on A (remaining balance 0) and 177.49 (carry over from A) on B. The following month, I pay 200 on B, etc. This all boils down to the sum of the minimums (1250) being paid on I each month until it's gone.

If I pay them off in the order above, I have estimated that I will be able to pay them all off by October 2022. This was calculated using a spreadsheet and copy/pasting the same formula over and over again for each month until the debt was paid down, and then copy/pasting that for each debt. However, this assumes that the carry over is going to the next item in the list. It may be faster however if the debt from B is moved to E instead of C.

My question is this. Is there a formula/program that would allow me to input this data, and it would calculate the fastest way to eliminate all of the debt above?

NOTE: This question is not focused on minimizing "potential savings lost" (ie. paying the debt with the highest interest rate first), but rather on minimizing the time taken to pay them all down.

  • are you only ever going to make the same total amount of payments each month? – costrom Apr 27 '16 at 23:14
  • 1
    @costrom if you mean am I ever only going to spend a maximum of 1250 a month on this, then the answer is no. For the immediate future it is a yes (due to job loss/gain/change), but come October, once I get everything to a stable level, I will be able to increase the total. If the answer is more simple assuming this is a constant unchanging amount, then we can do that. – Zymus Apr 27 '16 at 23:19
  • 2
    @Zymus - I think you answered your own question and didn't realize it. Suppose you pay a fixed amount per month, let's say $1500. If you minimize your "potential savings lost" by paying down the highest interest rate first, then the only way you can pay less total money than any other method is if you pay $1500/month for less time than any other method. This is why Eric Johnson's answer is correct. Highest APR first is the cheapest and also the fastest. – TTT Apr 28 '16 at 1:50
  • Actually, if you want to be pedantic, the "fastest way to eliminate all of the debt above", is to make 1 single payment of $62,063.98. – TTT Apr 28 '16 at 2:05
7

You don't need a program. The fastest way to pay off the debt is to make minimum payments to all debt except for the one with the highest interest rate and then put the remainder to that one debt. Then as soon as it is gone repeat with the next highest. This will minimize the amount of interest you are paying and the time to payoff.

You may not appear to make progress as quickly as with other methods (such as paying off the smallest one first), but in the long run you will finish first. However this does assume that you have the willingness to follow this approach to its completion. If you need some faster victories than the less efficient method of paying the smallest first may be better for you.

Also key to the above strategy is that you don't reduce the amount of money that you are putting too debt each month once you pay off any of the debt.

  • 2
    Don't forget it's the highest post-tax adjusted rate that should be attacked first. Assuming 35% tax bracket, a 10% mortgage is effectively just under 7%, and is dying for a refi but that's outside the scope of this question. – Aaron D. Marasco Apr 27 '16 at 23:53
  • @Aaron D. Marasco True if the OP puts the tax savings towards the debt. – Eric Johnson Apr 28 '16 at 0:33
  • Just to elaborate, the order in this specific case would work out to C,B,D, followed by G,H,I in any order and then F and E assuming it would still be open. A would have got closed by then. – Dheer Apr 28 '16 at 3:31
  • 1
    It looks like doing it by interest rate saves me about 7 months time (March '22 instead of October '22). In order of completion dates, it goes A, B, C, D, G, H, I, F, E. – Zymus Apr 28 '16 at 4:01

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.