3

Early non-exempt withdrawal from a Roth-IRA results in a "10% penalty". A 10% penalty on what amount: The amount withdrawn? The remaining balance of the Roth IRA? Both?

Insight appreciated

  • The only tax on an IRA balance is if you fail to take Required Minimum Distributions beginning at age 70.5 from a traditional IRA. If you contribute more than the amount allowed per year and don't correct it (up to the filing due date including extensions for that year) there is a tax on the excess contributions. – dave_thompson_085 Apr 24 '16 at 3:11
3

Ok, finally got this one figured out--pardon my earlier answer.

You owe a 10% penalty and income tax (not capital gains tax) on any gains you take out. That is, any amount you take out that is above the amount you contributed to the account.

Say your tax rate is 28% and you have an account with $15,000 in it, $5,000 of which is gains. If you take out $11,000, you owe the government 10% as a penalty plus 28% as tax of the $1000 you took out that was gains. So you owe $380.

Another example, if you take out $10,000 and you only had $5,000 of contributions in the account, then you owe 10% plus your tax rate (say, 20%) on the $5,000 you took out that was gains. That totals $5,000*(.10+.20)=$1,500. Note that you may need to provide proof of your contributions. Not sure whether the contribution amount applies to that Roth or all your Roth accounts...someone can tell us in the comments.

Bottom line: best to leave gains in there. Limit your early withdrawals to your contribution total only.

1

Unless an exception applies, most distributions from a Roth IRA before the owner reaches age 59 1/2 will be subject to an "early withdrawal penalty" of 10% on the amount of the distribution. Be very careful NOT to confuse the early withdrawal penalty with the taxes imposed on a non-qualified distribution. A non-qualified distribution imposes an ordinary income tax on the distribution, but the early withdrawal penalty will be imposed in addition to that tax.

If, for example, you are in a 20% tax bracket, withdrawing say $10,000 will cost $3,000 in penalty and taxes.

  • 5
    With one major exception. The tax and penalty are only on gains. And it's not prorated, deposits come out first. Even in normal times, it would take 7-10 years to double, so half or more can be withdrawn tax and penalty free. – JoeTaxpayer Apr 23 '16 at 22:35
  • Joe T is right, but one more quibble: for Roth distributions exceeding contributions (and rollovers) to be 'qualified' and escape (all) tax, you must be over 59.5 (or disabled, dead, or homebuyer) AND the account must have been open 5 years. For details and authority see pub 590-B chapter 2, current year online here and also available in PDF under irs.gov/Forms-&-Pubs . – dave_thompson_085 Apr 24 '16 at 3:02

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.