Source: p 336, Personal Finance For Canadians For Dummies (4 ed, 2006; but a 5 ed (2010) exists) by T. Martin, E. Tyson

“Cash value policies are all paid up after x years. You don’t want to be paying life insurance premiums for the rest of your life, do you?”

[...] Imagine that [1.] you’re currently paying $500 a year for auto insurance, and
[2.] an insurance company comes along and offers you a policy for $4,000 per year. The representative tells you that after 10 years, you can stop paying and still keep your same coverage.
[3.] We’re sure that you wouldn’t fall for this sales tactic, but many people do when they buy cash value life insurance.

I generalise the quote above to all insurance, and not only 'auto insurance'. Why is 3 deceptive and harmful? The use of We’re sure suggests something obvious which I have neglected.

I assume that one needs insurance for some good or service for at least 30 years. Then 2 (a total of $4,000 x 10 years) appears cheaper than ($500 x ? years), because the breakeven number of years is $4000*10/$500 = 80 years.


The breakeven amount isn't at 8 years. You calculated how many years of paying $500 it would take to break even with one year of paying $4000. 8 x 10 years = 80 years. So by paying $500/year it will take you 80 years to have spent the same amount ($40000 total) as you did in 10 years.

At this point it may seem obvious what the better choice is.

Consider where you'll be after 10 years:

In scenario #1 you've spent $5000 ($500*10) and have to continue spending $500/year indefinitely.

In scenario #2 you've spent $40000 ($4000*10) and don't have to pay any more, but you currently have $35000 ($40000 - $5000) less than you did in scenario #1.

If you had stayed with scenario #1 you could invest that $35000 at a measly 1.43% annual return and cover the $500 payments indefinitely without ever dipping into your remaining $35000. Most likely over the long term you'll do better than 1.43% per year and come out far ahead.

  • +1. Thank you! Ashamed, I repent for such a serious arithmetical error which I have emended in my OP. – Greek - Area 51 Proposal Mar 25 '16 at 5:19

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.