The situation

This is a specific situation, but hopefully the general themes of the question will be helpful to others. I read the question at In general, is it financially better to buy or to rent a house?, which provided a good sense of what to keep in mind. So, I am looking for advice that goes beyond these basic considerations.

We just moved into this place last August, on a 2-year lease. I came home yesterday to find a "for sale" sign in our yard, and an access box on our front door. I was pretty annoyed - my landlord gave us no warning (that he would be selling the house), and part of the reason we decided to rent this place was because we liked the guy.

Clarification: I should point out that the realtor is aware that they must give us 24 hours notice before showing the house, and so far has honored that. But still, we have busy lives and 24 hours is barely enough to, you know, make the place ready for strangers.

Technically our lease is with the property, not the person. So, the new owners would have to honor the remainder of our lease. However we live in a college town, and I dread the thought of one of the local slumlords becoming our new landlords.

The opportunity

I realized that I can also look at this as an opportunity. We have another 20 months on our lease, and the estimated (monthly) PITI based on his asking price is about 33% lower than our rent. We've lived here long enough to know that, other than needing a new roof, the place is in pretty good shape (which of course, we'd use to negotiate).

The house is not super-close to campus, but close enough that people are interested in renting (after all, we chose to live here, and the houses next door are also occupied by students).

Based on my calculations, we'd save several thousand dollars just over the course of our lease. Not to mention, the potential rental value of the place once we're ready to move.

The catch

Here are my hesitations: I have enough for a 20% down payment, but that represents nearly all of my liquid assets (which are currently invested in an S&P500 index fund). I would essentially be losing all of my diversification.

On top of that, this isn't exactly my dream house - it's comfortable, but too small. I'm also not sure how much longer we're going to be in this town. My girlfriend will finish her degree by the time our lease is up, after which we'll probably want to move out of this town. So, we'd have to sell the house again, or be absentee landlords.

Update: We do also own a small business in the town that we might end up remotely managing that from elsewhere. So it is possible that we could still have a tie to the town beyond the rental house.

Should I make him an offer? A couple already came by today to look at the property. It seems like I should probably act soon.

  • 4
    He cannot legally enter your apartment without proper notice and must get your permission as well as agreement on a time. I'd unscrew the doorknob and remove the box his real estate agent put on. The new owner will have to honor your lease as well, so even if you agree to let people in, you don't have to move. Feb 1, 2015 at 3:12
  • Ha, yeah, I was thinking about taking the box off. But, no point in antagonizing him unless things get ugly ;)
    – buymybook
    Feb 1, 2015 at 3:22
  • Fair enough, but he may be breaking the law, or laws. Feb 1, 2015 at 4:33
  • 9
    @buymybook anyone entering the property you've leased without your permission is trespassing. Having landlord's permission is not enough, even for the landlord himself. Trespassing is a criminal offense and you can get police involved if you wish to, or, more likely, housing/consumer regulatory agency. This is the biggest no-no for the landlord: once the property is leased up the landlord can no longer come and go as she wishes!
    – littleadv
    Feb 1, 2015 at 6:32

3 Answers 3


Never buy a house unless you really want to buy that house. If you want to buy a rental, look around and find the right rental to buy; saving a few hundred on moving costs isn't a good reason to buy the wrong property at the wrong price.

  • 3
    Thanks. But remember, I am still beheld to the current, 2-year lease. Plus, I have "insider information" on the condition of the house as I have lived in it for 5 months already.
    – buymybook
    Feb 1, 2015 at 16:21

Can he legally break your lease if he sells the place? If not I would just keep renting.

It doesn't sound like you love the house and you plan on moving or would prefer a different type of place long term. Unless you yourself plan on getting involved in being a renting it out to others in the future - just rent and move on at some point.

If he can break your lease upon sale of the property then I'd be casually keeping an eye out for another place to rent if that happens.

  • 1
    Well like I said, it could be pretty valuable as a rental property if our current rent is any indicator. I'm pretty sure he can't break our lease; it would be transferred to the new owner.
    – buymybook
    Feb 1, 2015 at 3:26
  • 1
    There are lots of investment options out there. It's unlikely that you fell into one. It's possible, but if you want to get into rentals - don't get attached to this one because you live in it. Start doing your research and becoming familiar with that business. There may be a better buy than yours. I also may have mis-understood, I assumed when your GF finished her degree you would be completely moving out of town. Having a single rental in a town you don't live in, will be a PITA and likely lose you plenty of money and be a headache.
    – Ryan Doom
    Feb 1, 2015 at 14:53

There are probably thousands of houses that you could buy. If you want to buy a house, it is very unlikely that the one you are renting right now is the best possible buy.

Usually people living in the houses they own are more interested in the quality of their property and the quality of their neigborhood than people who are renting, so I'd say that you are generally better off finding a home to buy in an area where the majority own their homes.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .