8

I don't have a ton to invest. I have $1,000 to put into a stock and I'm eying 3 of them. One is currently trading at ~$100/share, another at ~$260/share and another at ~$25/share. So I could get ~10 shares of the first, a bit less than 4 shares of the second or 40-ish shares of the third.

My question is, would there be any benefit to buying one or the other based on this? Is it better to have a bunch of shares or not?

I was thinking that the value of the stock is the value of the stock...the actual number of shares really doesn't matter, but I'm not sure.

Opinions?

Thank you!!

  • 1
    The price of the stock is driven by how many shares were issued and how much people think the company is worth, and will be worth. The first factor can change -- eg in a stock split -- without the others changing. So the question you've asked is the wrong one; what you really need to look at is what you think the future of that company looks like, and what that might do to the stock price and/or to the dividends it pays to stockholders. What matters is the multiplier on the whole amount -- and how likely each possible outcome is. – keshlam Mar 6 '15 at 20:17
13

There is no difference between more shares of a relatively cheaper stock and less shares of a relatively more expensive stock. When you invest in a stock, the percentage increase (or decrease) in the share price results in gains (or losses).

This is a fundamental concept of investing. Your question suggests that you would benefit from further research before investing your money. Trading real dollars can be difficult without a strong understanding of the principles involved. Investing your money without a good knowledge base will likely be stressful and could have a discouraging effect if it doesn't go well.

Before you open an investment account, read up on investing fundamentals, particularly mutual funds as those can be a great place to start as a new investor. There are many sources of information including books, websites such as http://investor.gov/investing-basics and this website. Don't skip the sections on taxes, as those matter just as much and sometimes more than the simple buying and selling. You might look at tax advantaged accounts, such as 401k's, IRA's, etc. It shouldn't take long but it will be one of the most important things you do as a beginning investor. Everyone has to start here. Understanding the vocabulary and concepts will likely save you time and money throughout your investing life.

  • 5
    A little learning before you start is the best investment you can make and asking questions is a great way to get there. – rhaskett Sep 3 '14 at 22:41
8

Unless your brokerage will sell you fractional shares, the most obvious difference (without us knowing the actual identify of the companies) is that with the $260 one, you will have 3 shares plus you will have $220 minus commission left over that you wanted to invest but weren't able to simply because of the mechanics of long division.

You could put that $220 into one of the cheaper stocks, but now the multiple commissions will start to eat your returns.

My personal opinion is you should go for a low cost index mutual fund or ETF, and wait to pick individual stocks until you have more than $1000 to work with (and even then, probably still go with the low cost index fund)

2

You are correct in thinking actual number of shares do not matter, the value is the value.

However there are cases where share price does play a role. Berkshire Hathaway for example has not split because Warren Buffet believes it has cut down on the liquidity of the stock, as well as attracting investors with an eye for the longer term.

There have also been things written on the psychology of a share price. For example, some people are attracted to shares that split, because it reflects a company is growing.

  • Small correction: Berkshire Hathaway hasn't split class A shares but B have been split before. – Ross Mar 2 '16 at 14:45
0

Open Google finance and divide the Market Capitalization by the total price. That will give you the total number of shares outstanding. Now see the number of shares you could buy for $1000(40 shares of $25 each or 10 shares of 100 shares each). Now divide the number of shares you own, by the number of shares outstanding in the company and multiply it by 100(i.e (Shares you own/shares Outstanding) * 100). That will give you the percentage or stake of the company you own(With $1000, don't expect it to be a very large number). Now ask your self the question, Is it worth it if I can buy x % of this company for $1000? If the answer is yes, go ahead and buy it.

To answer your question in short, NO! it does not matter whether you buy 10 shares for $100 or 40 shares for $25.

Cheers

0

I was thinking that the value of the stock is the value of the stock...the actual number of shares really doesn't matter, but I'm not sure.

You're correct. Share price is meaningless.

Google is $700 per share, Apple is $100 per share, that doesn't say anything about either company and/or whether or not one is a better investment over the other.

You should not evaluate an investment decision on price of a share. Look at the books decide if the company is worth owning, then decide if it's worth owning at it's current price.

-4

if you have 10 shares of $100/each and 100 shares of $10/each, if stock price goes up $1, then in first case you made $10 and in second case you made $100. So big difference!

  • 2
    Yes and if the price goes up 100% in the first case and -20% in the second case you wil have either 2,000 or 800 dollars. Looking at stockprices you look at percentual increases/decreases, nominal amount makes it difficult to compare between different stocks. – ssn Jan 23 '18 at 12:57

protected by Chris W. Rea Jan 23 '18 at 13:09

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.