A credit card I currently use offered me a credit limit increase. The current limit is $2500; I rarely spend over $500 on that card.

Let's say you have a legitimate reason for wanting more credit. My understanding is that requesting a credit limit increase and a new card both cause a hard pull. Since a lot of cards offer new sign up incentives, shouldn't you instead opt for one of those, assuming you can find an offer worth taking? Is there any advantage to getting a credit limit increase as opposed to getting a new card, assuming your current limit is already sufficient?

  • 1
    In my experience when the bank initiates the limit increase it's a soft pull, but when I initiate it it's sometimes a soft pull and sometimes a hard pull depending on the bank.
    – TTT
    Mar 8 '17 at 14:44

These are similar but one outcome is easier to manager

first: Hard Pull does negatively effect credit slightly ("new credit" on that chart)

second: A lower credit utilization ratio ("amounts owed" on the chart) increases your credit greater than a hard pull does.

In both scenarios (getting a new card vs increase on an existing card), if approved, you will have a lower credit utilization ratio, thereby increasing your credit if you keep that ratio low and pay minimums.

But if you just keep one card, and that card has a higher limit, then you will have more flexibility on the size of purchases you can make without effecting your utilization ratio. Making the option of a credit increase on an existing card easier to manage.

It is also more likely to get approved for a greater credit increase on an existing card than getting approved for a new card. (ie. its more likely you may get a store-specific nonvisa/nonmastercard/nonamericanexpress card, or a card with a low limit). So if you want to take chances with your hard pulls, know what you are more likely to get instead of wasting a hard pull.

  • 1
    +1 - I added an answer to discuss account age. New cards' impact on account age takes years to pass, unless the card is cancelled after a bonus period has expired. Sep 15 '12 at 14:52
  • Well, in this particular situation Citi assured me there would be no hard pull. There's one advantage.
    – Brad Koch
    Sep 18 '12 at 3:45

There are lots of reasons to choose a credit card: effect on your score would not be the top one for me. I would use, in order:

  • having at least two cards so if one is compromised and you're waiting for your new card to come in the mail, you still have one
  • having different rewards perks - eg 1 card gives 4% at the grocery store, 1% elsewhere, while another gives 4% at the drugstore, 1% elsewhere. Use whichever card give you 4% at the store you're in
  • having an alternate brand for the "we only take visa" or "we only take mastercard" scenarios - these are rarer these days, but still happen
  • enjoying a generous signup bonus
  • simplifying personal accounting such as using one card only for vacation expenses or one for needs and one for wants

And as downside:

  • two annual fees if you're choosing cards with fees
  • two bills to pay and possibly a service charge for paying the bill

This leads me to having 2 or 3 personal cards, no more. If I have a legit need for credit above their total limits, I would meet that by allowing the limits to be raised, not by getting a 4th or 5th card.

  • Wow. A great answer on this one. For point one - I've had cards shut down due to 'suspicious' usage. Once, when I was making my annual charity donations. Easy, as I was home, and just had to make a call. The other time, I was in a store on vacation, and no time or privacy to make the call on the spot, so the 2nd card was right there. Mar 8 '17 at 14:57

One of the scoring factors is average age of accounts. That score is dinged for new ones (obviously) but looking ahead, I'd rather have 5 10 year old accounts than 1 account with a high credit line.

In How Old is Your Credit Card I show the range of scores vs age of accounts. Ideally, you want your credit cards to be over 8 years old. Now, if only my 13 year old card issuer would stop having security breaches and when issuing a new card treat it as brand new, I'd be happier.

The sign up incentives will impact your score, of course. It's a game you should be very careful playing, especially up to two years prior to buying a home or refinancing.

  • I've read that credit cards you cancel do not fall off your credit report until 10 years after. This leads me to understand that even if you cancel a card, that cancelled card's age is averaged into the "Length of credit history" for 10 years.
    – Sun
    Sep 5 '14 at 16:28
  • 1
    @SunWKim - Correct. So, when I cleaned up what I thought was "too many" accounts, and cancelled a few card a decade ago, I just saw my score drop as those accounts just fell off my report. Sep 5 '14 at 19:05

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.