I am 25 and on my parent's plan until I turn 26 on December 25, 2020. It has pre-authorized me for a surgery which is currently scheduled for November 17.

However I want to reschedule it to after I turn 26 for two reasons.

  • I have 0 symptoms and the surgery is not urgent.
  • My parent's plan is catastrophic and I would be covering the entire family out-of-pocket max of $4.5k. I am young and healthy so my new plan would likely have an out-of-pocket max around $3k.
  • My girlfriend is able to come help me recover from surgery but not till 2021 when I will be on my own plan.

I am self-employed and my income is above the medicare limit.

The ACA prohibits insurers from denying or charing higher premiums based on pre-existing conditions (which I presume a pre-scheduled surgery would fall under). It is not for the common ones eg diabetes, cancer, heart disease.

My current insurance has pre-authorized the surgery for November 17.

If I get new insurance (same insurance but now my own plan—so it definitely does cover the surgery under normal circumstances) will they be required to cover the surgery?

Is there some income limit to being eligible for these plans?

  • 1
    When you say "same insurance" do you mean "same insurance company" or "same insurance plan"? The same company can offer a variety of plans that would cover a variety of things and can potentially involve different sets of providers. Oct 4, 2020 at 14:14
  • @JustinCave I mean another insurance company who covers this surgery under normal circumstances. Assume that this company would, if I had them right now, cover this surgery. Oct 5, 2020 at 14:44

2 Answers 2


No, they don't, but we need to be very precise in what we're discussing

There are a couple of ways your main question can be read:

  1. Will the new insurer cover a service that their insurance contract includes, even if I know I will need that service in advance of signing that contract?

  2. Can I obtain approval for a surgical procedure under my current insurance, and then maintain that approval seamlessly while switching to a new plan or new insurer?

These have different answers, and some implications that are relevant.

1. Will the new insurer cover a service that their insurance contract includes, even if I know I will need that service in advance of signing that contract?

This is an unambiguous "yes", provided that the surgery is related to, or is itself, an essential medical benefit under the ACA, and the new insurance is an ACA-compliant plan. The essential benefits portions of the ACA mandate that ACA-compliant insurance plans must cover a large number of services treating a large number of medical conditions. Other portions of the ACA mandate that an insurer cannot deny you coverage or charge you a different premium for such a benefit because you happen to need it (whether you already know about it or not).

So the considerations are: i.) is this plan ACA-compliant? ii.) is this medical service an essential medical benefit?

If the answer to both of those is "yes", then the insurer will likely have to cover the surgery.

2. Can I obtain approval for a surgical procedure under my current insurance, and then maintain that approval seamlessly while switching to a new plan or new insurer?

This is an unambiguous "no". While the insurer must provide coverage for essential services, they still have their own procedures that must be satisfied before they can be compelled to pay. Your question indicates that this surgery has already been pre-authorized by your current insurer. That is worthless with respect to a different insurer which has not yet pre-authorized the surgery, and of unclear value with respect to a new insurance plan under the same insurer.

It is unlikely that the new insurer would outright deny to cover an essential benefit, but they may have different procedures involved in pre-authorizing a specific service. For example, the new insurer may want to see evidence that you have pursued non-surgical interventions first without relief while the old insurer might not have such a policy.

There are also provider networks to consider. If your current insurer (or plan) includes Facility A in their network, but the new insurer (or plan) does not, then the new insurer (or plan) is not going to pay for the surgery at Facility A (or may not pay the same rates with the same cost-sharing arrangements).

Finally, even if you use the same insurer in both instances you may not be on the same insurance plan, and that is an important factor to check. If you're currently on Parental Corp.'s Premium Health Freedom Plus plan through the insurer Health Co. (plans tend to have florid, non-descriptive names), and your own insurance would be the Deluxe Health Liberty Choice plan through Health Co., the specifics of your benefits may differ in ways you can't observe, let alone predict. It is also possible that your existing pre-authorization will expire before your new, preferred surgery date.

The insurer's responsibility with respect to your medical bills depends on the specific plan they offer (though high-level considerations, like "is this essential service covered?" will not change).

The bottom line: don't assume that you can maintain an existing permission, like a pre-approval, while switching among insurance plans or insurers.

Some other considerations:

  1. I do not recommend assuming much about what your new plan will be like. It's definitely possible that you will find an ACA-compliant plan which offers similar coverage to what you have now, but with a lower out-of-pocket maximum. But it's just as possible, if not more so, that you will find yourself with an OOP max of $4,500 to $5,000.

  2. While ACA-compliant plans are required to cover certain services for all applicants, they aren't required to offer the same insurance policies to everyone. If you're on your parents' insurance right now, there is a good chance that they have that policy through an employer's group policy. It is unusual for a small firm or individual (depending on your exact status as a self-employed person) to have access to the same insurance plans larger employers do, though it certainly can happen. But applying for something like an individual coverage plan is unlikely to be as favorable to you as a group plan would be (exceptions abound, but be mindful of this).

  3. Your age is not as helpful to you as you might think. It is possible that you can get a better policy, but in the same way that you cannot be underwritten to your detriment by an insurer due to this pre-existing condition, you cannot be underwritten to your benefit due to your age. There are insurance plans that will give you some consideration as a young customer, but that leads to (4), below. I would not bet much on any individual or small-group health plan having an OOP max much below $5,000. It can absolutely happen, but I would not depend on it for financial planning, unless you already have a policy outline in hand that says so.

  4. There are many insurance plans available that are not ACA-compliant. These are often aimed at people looking for a better deal on their insurance, typically evaluated by monthly premium costs. You will be able to find such a plan (depending somewhat on your state's regulations), but these do not need to cover essential medical benefits, nor are they bound by many other provisions of the ACA. Whether or not you want to pursue such a plan is up to you, but I recommend establishing in advance whether or not this procedure is covered and whether or not you bear similar risk under your new plan.

  5. Things can change. There is currently an ACA-related lawsuit heading to the Supreme Court, and depending on how that case goes you might find 2021 to be a wildly different environment for health insurance and health care than 2020.

  6. There aren't income limits for private insurance plans, though some programs that defray costs, available through ACA marketplaces, do. If you are eligible to participate in a plan and can afford the premium, you can't make too much money to qualify.


No, they are not required to cover it. When you switch, you will need to have the surgery re-approved under the new plan/provider. The negotiated rates could be different, if you switch providers (insurance company) the doctor may no longer be in-network, the doctor/hospital's rates could change in 2021, etc. Your new plan may have a different out-of-pocket, but what will the deductible, co-pay, and/or co-insurance be? There's more variables at play other than just whether or not a surgery was authorized. I would say the chances are high that they will cover the surgery if it's an actual medical procedure and not an elective one.

"Pre-existing conditions" just means they're not allowed to deny insuring you or charge more for the plan (AKA premium) than they would have without the condition. The premium is the monthly amount you pay and is completely independent of the cost for this specific surgery.

If you already know who the new insurance carrier will be, you can ask your doctor's billing department if they are in-network and if they anticipate a difference in negotiated rates. Make sure specifically to ask if they are "in-network" and don't ask "do you take/accept". Out-of-network doctors will take/accept most insurance, but you'll have to pay significantly more.

  • I know they are not required to cover it but that was not my question. My question is, if they would usually cover it anyway, will they cover it after just having switched to them? Or will they deny coverage considering the surgery is a liability of insuring me known prior to the beginning of my coverage? Oct 5, 2020 at 14:44
  • @DerekFulton If it's something that the insurance covers, then the insurance will cover it by definition. They cannot deny coverage for that (or any) service because the fact that you have a scheduled surgery is a "liability" (that's what the pre-existing conditions provisions of the ACA address). Whether or not you can maintain an already-scheduled appointment is less clear, but I would suggest not assuming that you can.
    – Upper_Case
    Oct 5, 2020 at 16:09
  • @DerekFulton - The question in your post is literally "...will they be required to cover the surgery?" I followed with a statement that says chances are high they will cover it and explained pre-existing conditions issues, which means they can't deny you coverage. I'm not clear what I'm missing, so please let me know and I'll amend my answer.
    – BobbyScon
    Oct 5, 2020 at 16:56

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .