Context: I'm 23 y/o, live with family for obvious financial reasons. While I do pay for all the pet care/internet and some communal food/fuel I obviously am still mooching a lot from my parents.

The amount I'm saving doing this is crazy. From living alone and working full time I would spend 70% of pay-check on fundamental necessities. Now thats down to 20%. Which was enough for me to save 50k in a couple of years.

I know that money just sitting in a savings account is a bit of a waste so I really wanted to do SOMETHING with it. I looked into buying an investment property but while I have enough for the downpayment, I am paid minimum wage and I also reduced my hours so that I could study while working. So I didn't think I was earning enough to confidently maintain mortgage payments.

I spent a lot of time thinking about if and where I should invest. Asked some early beginner questions in this stack too. My savings goal is just to maximise money so that after I finish studying in a couple years, I can be well off enough to apply for jobs anywhere knowing I would have the financial capability to make a deposit on a house in that area. I may not immediately buy, I just want to have the capability to do so. Because this could happen as early as just 2 years from now, there is a good chance the investment would only be for 2 years. Unfortunately the only style of investing I was comfortable with would be long term, where my plan would be to simply select a bunch of companies from various index funds, and then let the money sit there for 10+ years. Anyway, in the end I could never muster the courage to invest anything, since its only for 2 years, holds a fair amount of risk and I know I am a complete novice, I didn't feel confident enough to make the right decisions.

Months passed with the money just sitting in savings and I have finally just thrown it all into a 2 year term deposit at my local bank (National Australia Bank) because I clearly wasn't doing anything else with the money. 1.15% is tiny, but its actually better than what the other banks in my area offer. Just 1.15% definitely still feels like a waste. Did I make a mistake?

  • 2
    Was this a mistake? I wouldn't begin to offer judgement since I have no clue what other choices are available in Australia. What I would suggest is that time permitting, you begin the process of becoming financially literate so that you are no longer a complete novice and you can begin to make the right decisions. Start reading. – Bob Baerker Feb 7 '20 at 2:26
  • The "cash rate" at the Reserve Bank of Australia is 0.75%, and the inflation rate in Dec 2019 was 1.8%. Thus, I'd say that a 1.15% TD is reasonable for a short term deposit. – RonJohn Feb 7 '20 at 5:12
  • 1
    Just a quick search online I found a term deposit rate of 2.05% over 24 months and many others around 1.5%. Maybe you didn't shop around enough! – Victor Feb 10 '20 at 6:36

The most important thing you did was have the opportunity and discipline to save a significant amount at a young age; this was not a mistake. You might have earned a little more in the next 2 years in a more sophisticated investment, but even if you'd got a great yield of 5%, that is only $4k difference. And if you'd made some unsuitable high-risk investment as a novice, you might have lost all $50k.

Your $51k (plus what you continue to save) will be there in 2 years for you to make good decisions with based on all the knowledge you will have by then -- whether for an emergency fund, home purchase, and/or long-term investments. The savings habit you've established will be far more valuable over your life than 2 years' return on $50k.

I salute you and see no mistake here.


Since Australia is possibly at risk of a recession due to a growing slowdown in China, the two-year bank deposit is a very good investment.

However, a two-year government-bond in a brokerage account could show a gain in value if there were a recession. In fact a two-year government-bond in a brokerage account could be leveraged if such economic views are held. Or a leveraged government-bond ETF might be found. Another choice is gold but probably not gold-mining stocks.

Or if the Australian currency were hedged with a sell of the AUD/USD then the position could receive a small rollover interest, probably 1/4 of one percent, on the leveraged amount.

Other choices, if not expecting recession, are bank stocks, telecommunications stocks, and real estate stocks. Basically, this is an equity-income category.

  • 2
    The probability of recession has already been priced into all of these by professionals. Would you really advise a novice to try to beat them at market timing/arbitrage? – nanoman Feb 7 '20 at 3:42
  • The news is daily. The epidemic in China could be increasing or decreasing. I mentioned two different economic views but I kept the second view as non-export related. – S Spring Feb 7 '20 at 3:44
  • 1
    Risk of recession? Leveraged government-bond ETFs? Gold? Hedging a leveraged AUD/USD position? Stock sectors to invest in? The OP is a noob wondering about basic cash equivalents. This is sledgehammer advice for a person who has no clue what a tack is. KYC. – Bob Baerker Feb 7 '20 at 13:59
  • I suggested a two-year government-bond instead of the two-year bank deposit. The two-year government-bond can have an intermediate gain accounted if interest rates decline. And risk-of-recession is in the news in Australia. Certainly more discussion followed. – S Spring Feb 7 '20 at 23:04

Possibly a big mistake, but being australian your options are limited unless you are willing to take currency risk.

I.e. I have some of my funds in a financial institution in switzerland paying me 8% in daily available funds, but they only accept deposits in EUR, USD or GBP - so one woul have to leave the australian dollar or hedge this risk, which add significant complication for someone not fluent with forex operations.

Given from what australia looks like from a european perspective you may be better buying gold - there are chances all major economies will get into some higher inflation brackets soonish, stocks are overpriced, australia what I hear has a terribly overprived real estate market. Which means there really are not a lot of options - and your interest rate will already with that inflation result in a net loss of purchasing power.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.