As an example, silver took a 9.4% hit on 9/22/2011, which was a bad market day -- the Dow dropped over 3.5%.

The conventional wisdom is that precious metals like silver are a hedge against a falling market. What are the factors that would make it swing so wildly in value?

  • 2
    Reopened based on edits to make this a viable question and 3 votes to-reopen subsequent to those edits. Cleaned up prior comments. Oct 11, 2011 at 13:06

2 Answers 2


The S&P 500 represents a broadly diversified basket of stocks. Silver is a single metal. If all else is equal, more diversification means less volatility. A better comparison would be the S&P 500 vs. a commodities index, or silver vs. some individual stock.


Silver is a commodity. It's valuable for certain kinds of manufacturing, jewelry, and as a speculative financial instrument or hedge against the dollar.

The S&P 500 includes companies which make money off of mining, manufacturing, medicine, media, technology, banking, dining, agriculture... There's a lot more variety there.

  • Thanks. This question was edited / changed from the original. My original question was why silver dropped 3 times as much as gold in the recent sell-off (gold drop from summer high of $1900). More recently comparing the two, I imagine it is because silver got more ahead price-wise than gold did, but am not sure. In any case, thanks for your comment.
    – Ray K
    Oct 12, 2011 at 3:24

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .