I was very surprised to receive a letter from a collection agency regarding a medical bill incurred during my wife's pregnancy last year. We never received any correspondence via mail, e-mail, or telephone regarding this debt. I assume that the hospital failed to pass along our insurance information to the provider, and instead of making a simple phone call they chose to turn it over to a collection agency.

The bills total over $1500 which is not an insignificant amount to take out of my savings. However, if it had been submitted to insurance it would have been fully paid (our deductible having been satisfied).

I have excellent credit and have never had anything placed with a collection agency before, so the way this was handled makes me very angry.

I am preparing to send written notice to the agency requesting verification of the debt. However, assuming they provide such verification, what is my recourse here? Obviously I'd like the provider to take the debt back and file it with insurance as should have been done in the first place - but I don't know that there's any way to make that happen. Do I have any recourse other than paying in full to the collection agency?

  • 5
    What does the hospital say?
    – RonJohn
    Jul 2, 2019 at 3:28
  • 1
    Country? State (if US)?
    – Brythan
    Jul 2, 2019 at 10:40
  • 2
    Once you get the verification, you should also call your insurance company and make sure they didn't receive anything about the bill. They might have a procedure to deal with this, or if not could reimburse you for what they would have paid. Jul 2, 2019 at 11:40

1 Answer 1


You mentioned in your question that the bill would have been paid by the insurance plan. In the US, insurance plans have timely filing deadlines - they vary from plan to plan, but can be as short as 90 days. Providers under contract with the plan are not allowed to bill the plan or the patient after that deadline, the debt is essentially a write off at that point. So, while you wait for the debt collector to validate the collection, the place to start is with your insurance plan - make sure the provider is in network and the services are covered. If they are, and the plan never received the claim, ask the plan to help communicate with the provider. Usually a provider will give up on a small bill like this under pressure from an insurance plan they're under contract with.

If the plan did receive the claim prior to the deadline, but didn't pay it for some reason, you will need to work with them to understand what happened - mainly, why you didn't receive an EOB explaining their decision (which they're required to provide) - and you can ask them to handle the provider for you.

If the provider isn't in network or otherwise has no affiliation with the plan, your next step is to contact the hospital and ask them why this provider's bill is being submitted separately from the rest of their services. Some types of providers are stereotypically bad about billing within hospital guidelines (i.e. anesthesiologists will sometimes automatically submit their own bills even though their services may be covered by the hospital's billing). Sometimes these situations occur because an in-network hospital will bring in one out of network provider to do one specific service for something as complicated as a pregnancy. If the hospital did this, they're responsible for negotiating payment with the provider and your insurance plan, the provider can't directly bill you (even though many will, out of automated-billing-induced ignorance). In these cases, the hospital will usually be willing to help deal with the provider to get the bill handled correctly.

As a last resort, you can contact the provider directly and ask for an explanation. Maybe they had your address wrong or were otherwise operating under the assumption that you were receiving bill(s) and notices about the money due. Or maybe there was an issue in their system that stopped them from billing you. Even if the insurance won't cover the services and has no leverage because the provider is out of network, or the provider is claiming they did bill correctly (and you somehow never got the bill), providers generally aren't in the business of beating people up over money and are usually happy to negotiate some sort of settlement.

All of the above steps should (hopefully) resolve the debt in a way that makes the collection attempt illegitimate. The plan, hospital, or provider should resolve that with the collections agency. If the debt is resolved through no fault of your own, and the collection account doesn't disappear off your credit report, you can contact the credit bureaus directly and file a dispute, providing them with whatever documentation you get as a result of the settlement, and the bureaus will remove the account from your report. If it turns out it was your fault (you received a bill but didn't remember, or something) you can still negotiate a "pay to remove" settlement with the collector. There's lots of good info on google about dealing with collections that are valid, so that may be a good step if it's a valid collection.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .