I own a condo, and its market value is less than what I owe on the mortgage. On the upside, several interesting developments are going in nearby in the next couple of years.

Because of some lifestyle changes, I want to buy a house in the same municipality, and rather than sell the condo low and take a rather large non-deductable loss, I want to rent out the condo.

What are the tax implications of doing this? If the condo is no longer my primary residence, am I forbidden from deducting mortgage interest?

If I put the condo in an LLC, would I have to sell the condo to the LLC, take some loss, and then get taxed on whatever gains the LLC makes when it sells the condo one day?

1 Answer 1


When you rent out your condo you'll tally up all the rent received and then you deduct from that amount all expenses to come up with your profit/loss. The portion of your mortgage payment that goes toward principal is not an expense that offsets rental income, so just because it would rent for less than your mortgage payment doesn't necessarily mean you'd have rental loss (though it's likely).

Here are some common rental expenses:

  • mortgage interest
  • insurance
  • HOA dues
  • property tax
  • maintenance/repairs
  • depreciation

After the dust settles on rent vs expenses you'd have your profit or loss from renting. Losses may or may not help your tax situation, it depends on your income and whether or not you are a real estate professional, if your modified AGI is over $150k and you aren't a real estate professional, your rental losses can't offset ordinary income, so no benefit. However, it still may be better than selling at a loss presently, as you are building equity with each payment.

Regarding an LLC, there's not a strong need to form an LLC for rentals but many do choose to do that, rather than selling your property to the LLC you'd most likely want to transfer it as a capital contribution. If it's a single-member LLC (and you don't elect to be taxed as a corporation) then for tax purposes it is no different than if you didn't have an LLC.

When you sell the condo, if it's within 3 years of moving out you would still qualify for the capital gains exemption from selling your primary residence, but if it is currently underwater that might not be a concern.

I'd suggest a lot of research before diving in, there are a great many sites/forums dedicated to landlords and it may be worthwhile to consult with a tax professional to get advice that is tailored to your specific financial situation.

One more important thing to factor in to your decision that many get mixed up on: While you need to depreciate a rental property and that depreciation expense does help offset income each year, it comes back around when you sell the property (depreciation recapture) unless you sell at a loss or sell it and buy another rental property (but that just kicks the tax can down the road).

Finally, buying another property without selling your current one means you need to have enough income to have an acceptable debt to income ratio with both mortgages factored in, lenders will typically not give you credit for potential rental income, my lender counts ~70% of my rental income and only started doing so after I had shown rental income on 2 tax returns.

  • I don't know the answer (otherwise I'd post it myself); as this answer does note depreciation a point of clarification: does the OP depreciate the actual basis from purchase date (which may be greater than the current value), or the market value on the day the condo goes into service?
    – user662852
    Jan 17, 2019 at 16:12
  • 1
    @user662852 I didn't want to get too in the weeds on all that, but it's the lesser of fair-market value and modified basis at time of conversion less land value (not typically relevant with condos), depreciated over 27.5 years.
    – Hart CO
    Jan 17, 2019 at 16:17
  • @Hart CO, thanks for your insights. Is there anything I could do that would be worse financially, all else being equal, than just selling the condo outright for a loss tomorrow? This would be unfortunate but not life-derailing, so I'm trying to understand both the best and worst decisions I can make here.
    – Bort
    Jan 17, 2019 at 17:11
  • 1
    @schadjo Well renting could be worse if you aren't prepared financially to deal with bad tenants or major repairs, but depending on how much gap you'd be left covering between rent and mortgage it sounds like renting could help you come out ahead if the local market really is poised for a comeback. If you delayed buying a house that could be wise. If you do buy and rent out the condo, I'd advise buying something inexpensive enough that you aren't cash starved, that could really put you in jeopardy.
    – Hart CO
    Jan 17, 2019 at 17:24

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .